Teacher Advocate

A place for educators and parents to share ideas –

Archive for the 'Concern for boys learning' Category

Project-Based Learning Engages All!

Boosting Student Engagement Through Project-Based Learning

A researcher-practitioner partnership in San Francisco shows promising results for middle school science students.

Taji Allen-Sanchez, a sixth- and seventh-grade science teacher at San Francisco’s Aptos Middle School, is one of a growing number of teachers who believe that traditional methods of teaching aren’t preparing students for life beyond school. Lectures and direct instruction can be used to convey information to students, but they don’t enhance skills like teamwork, problem solving, and curiosity that employers are increasingly looking for.

“If you just give students answers, they’re not going to understand [the science],” he explains. “Really, any kid can memorize information, but can they apply it to an actual real-world application?”

George Lucas Educational Foundation

2013 survey of over 700 business leaders bears out Allen-Sanchez’s point: Half of the respondents reported that many job applicants who were technically proficient lacked the communication, decision-making, and problem-solving skills necessary to do the jobs they applied for. Far too many college graduates touted high grades and test scores, but lacked key skills to be successful in the workplace.

“It’s not a matter of technical skill,” explained one employer in the survey, “but of knowing how to think.”

Aptos Middle School

Public, Urban
Grades 6-8
San Francisco, CA


In an attempt to foster those necessary skills, Allen-Sanchez uses a combination of project-based learning (PBL) and performance assessments to encourage his students to gain a deeper understanding of science. The curriculum he uses came out of a Stanford project looking at how PBL, paired with performance assessments, can boost student learning. The results so far have been promising: The three-year project revealed significant growth in state standardized English language arts (ELA) and math tests for students in the program. Significantly, teachers also reported seeing higher rates of participation and engagement for their students.

The program’s focus on academic discourse was especially helpful for English language learners, who outperformed their peers on the state’s measure of language proficiency.

Research shows that by organizing learning around meaningful goals, PBL can be an effective way to cultivate a “need to know” attitude in students—students are motivated to deepen their understanding in order to solve a problem that is meaningful to them. Concepts are better understood when students see a need for their use because that need encourages them to apply what they’re learning to relevant situations, leading to a better sense of understanding.

In schools participating in the study, students took an active role in their classrooms, asking questions, solving problems, conducting experiments, and participating in group discussions. The students felt that their assignments were more interesting, challenging, worthwhile, and enjoyable than did students in classrooms with a traditional science curriculum. Researchers also observed higher rates of students staying on task and paying close attention to the teacher and their peers.


Project-based learning can be a catalyst for transforming science learning, helping students move from asking “what?” to also asking “why?” and “how?” In a traditional classroom, students often focus on memorizing facts to pass a test. At Aptos Middle School and other schools across San Francisco, PBL is being used to encourage scientific inquiry, putting students in the shoes of scientists applying authentic reasoning practices—such as experimentation and trial and error—in the classroom. While students still learn facts, they also learn to apply those facts in open-ended projects that they help design.

This transformation is driven by the 5E model, which eschews a traditional “scope and sequence” approach in which students progress along a fixed path of concepts and skills throughout the school year. Instead, instruction is organized around five phases:

  • Engage: Students’ interest is piqued with novel ideas.
  • Explore: Hands-on activities deepen understanding.
  • Explain: Students describe ideas in their own words.
  • Elaborate: Ideas are applied to a broader context.
  • Evaluate: Students provide a rich picture of their understanding.

Allen-Sanchez explains that this model “really pushes kids to take an experience, really get immersed in it, learn about it through articles, and conversation, and discussion, and then get into more of it through the Elaborate by pushing what they already know to give more answers.”

Students in Allen-Sanchez’s science classes do more than just recite correct answers—they develop projects that utilize the 5Es. For example, students may work in groups to solve real-life engineering challenges such as working with a restaurant to design an energy-efficient kitchen. These students learn STEM concepts like the impact that windows and doorways have on thermal insulation, and they apply those concepts in complex situations: working with clients, managing projects, and executing the design cycle of prototyping, testing, and revising solutions to solve problems.

“We knew that we wanted to create a science environment in our classrooms that would disrupt the way that it had become: a course in which facts were learned and memorized,” said Jim Ryan, the former STEM executive director for the San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD).


Despite the importance of team problem-solving in today’s workplaces, only 8 percent of students could meet the demands of a highly collaborative environment, while 28 percent would struggle because they have only basic levels of important skills. Schools largely aren’t addressing this skills mismatch—highlighting the need for more opportunities for students to work together to solve the complex problems that do foster the necessary skills.

At the beginning of every school year, teachers in SFUSD emphasize the need for students to work together, not just to complete challenging projects but also to help change beliefs and stereotypes about science identity.

“We recognize that students walk in the door of this classroom with issues of status behind them, that they recognize themselves as being a science person or a non-science person,” said Ryan. “It’s through student discourse and group work that they will start to dispel those beliefs about not only themselves but about their peers, and recognize that each of those students is bringing an aspect of smarts into the problem that they’re trying to solve around science.”

Throughout the year, teachers use group work to address the myth that scientists work in isolation. For Eric Lewis, the district’s science content specialist, science “requires lots of people with lots of different specializations to work together to explain an idea and to come up with solutions for the big problems that we have today.”


To improve student learning, start with teachers—that’s the philosophy driving project-based learning in SFUSD. In a landmark study, John Hattie found that teachers account for 30 percent of the variance in student achievement, beating other factors like quality of curriculum, class size, and school funding. So after Stanford developed the new science curriculum (which can be downloaded for free), SFUSD educators worked with the researchers to improve it, playing a key role as co-designers.

“In developing this curriculum, it was absolutely critical that it was a true partnership. One, not only between Stanford and San Francisco, but between teachers, designers, administrators, etc.,” said Nicole Holthuis, a Stanford researcher and one of the creators of the curriculum. Teachers took the curriculum into their classrooms to test out and then gave each other feedback on what worked and what didn’t.

The partnership seems to be effective: Lewis says that with the 5E model and PBL, “We’re seeing more students getting their hands wet. We’re seeing more students contribute ideas. We’re seeing more students participate in many different ways.”

The Learning Through Performance study was supported by Edutopia’s sister division, Lucas Education Research. Both organizations are funded by the George Lucas Educational Foundation.

posted by lgilliam in "SOS" SAVE OUR STUDENTS!,Concern for boys learning,Parent and have No Comments



posted by lgilliam in "SOS" SAVE OUR STUDENTS!,Better Health for all,Brain Study in Girls and Boys,Concern for boys learning,Educational Frustrations,Heroes of schools,Parent,Uncategorized,UNDERSTANDING and have No Comments

10 Reasons the U.S Educational System is Failing!

Your daily education news and insight for August 27, 2015. View as web page.
No other American city has experienced as much upheaval to public schooling than New Orleans has in the decade since Hurricane Katrina. A Special Project: The Re-Education of New Orleans.
VIDEOS The Last Word on New Orleans SchoolsCan post-Katrina schools deliver a high-quality education for all children regardless of race and income? Hear from those with the biggest stake in the answer and share your thoughts in this final installment of Education Week‘s special coverage of dramatic public school changes in New Orleans since the storm. View the full package.

Share your “last word” on the evolution of public schooling in New Orleans with #NOLAlastword.
In Math Work Stations Debbie Diller presents over 70 stations for grades K-2 on beginning number concepts, addition & subtraction, place value, geometry, and measurement. You’ll see how to introduce stations through whole-group & mini-lessons. Includes 300+ full-color photos from real classrooms. Click here now to preview Chapter 1!
Minecraft Fueling Creative Ideas, Analytical Thinking in K-12 ClassroomsOne of the world’s most popular video games has made significant inroads into K-12 classrooms for teaching everything from city planning to physics. Read more. (Education Week)
Wash. State Lawmakers Face Hard Choices on K-12 FinanceTensions remain among legislators as they seek to hammer out a school funding plan amid $100,000 a day in court-ordered sanctions. Read more. (Education Week)
OPINION 10 Reasons the U.S. Education System Is Failing“Let’s examine 10 problems that prevent the U.S. education system from regaining its former pre-eminence,” writes opinion blogger Matthew Lynch. Read more. (Education Futures)
OPINION Teachers and District Leaders Should Work TogetherTeachers need not be intimidated by administrators when working on collaboration for the future, says teacher mentor Precious Crabtree. Read more. (Teacher)
Calif. Ed. Dept. Deletes History of Test Results Before Releasing New Scores
(Curriculum Matters)
Presidential Contenders’ Websites Skimpy on K-12 Policy
(Politics K-12)
Kentucky Board Shortens List of Commissioner Candidates to Five
(State EdWatch)
Catholic Schools Add ‘R’ for Religion to Turn STEAM to STREAM
(Curriculum Matters)
Chicago to Conduct Citywide Audit of Services for ELLs
(Learning the Language)
Mediation Between Ariz. Legislature, Schools Fails
(Associated Press)
Calif. Governor Approves Exit Exam Reprieve for 5,000 Students
(Associated Press)
Should Kindergarten Be Mandatory?
(Walt Gardner’s Reality Check)
13 Tips for Writing College Recommendations That Rock
(Work in Progress)
Helping Teachers and Schools Run Experiments
(Vander Ark on Innovation)
Careful How You Use Those Test Scores
(The K-12 Contrarian)
What Ed. Resources Would You Share?
(Reinventing K-12 Learning)
Extending Welcome to New Leaders
(Leadership 360)


1. Big Hype, Hard Fall for News Corp.’s $1 Billion Ed-Tech Venture


2. Great School Culture: It Starts With the Principal (Teaching While Leading Blog)


3. Illinois Governor Signs Sweeping School Discipline Bill Championed by Students (Rules for Engagement Blog)


4. Polls Reveal Nuanced Views on K-12


5. What to Do the First Day of School (and Why) (Opinion)
+ Account Manager, Standard Accounts (Ohio) Northwest Evaluation Association, OH
+ Sr. Account Executive Northwest Evaluation Association, Multiple Locations
+ Account Manager, Standard Accounts (Iowa) Northwest Evaluation Association, IA
+ Assistant Superintendent, Human Resources Fairfax County Public Schools, VA, Falls Church, VA
+ Head of School Montessori Center School, Goleta, CA
+ Principal Prep, Omaha, NE
Browse top education jobs. Search Jobs>>
Recruit top education professionals. Post a Job>>
Update Preferences   |    Customer Care   |    Editor Feedback   |    Advertising
This message was intended for lgilliam@teacheradvocate.com. You are receiving this free e-newsletter because you requested it when you registered on edweek.org or teachermagazine.org. To change your e-newsletter subscriptions or other email preferences, please click here.This free e-newsletter is a service of Editorial Projects in Education, Inc., 6935 Arlington Road, Suite 100, Bethesda, MD 20814. EPE is the publisher of Education Week, Digital Directions, Teacher Professional Development Sourcebook, edweek.org, teachermagazine.org, DigitalDirections.org, TeacherSourcebook.org, and TopSchoolJobs.org.Copyright © 2015 Editorial Projects in Education.


posted by lgilliam in "SOS" SAVE OUR STUDENTS!,Brain Study in Girls and Boys,Coaching,Concern for boys learning,Educational Frustrations,Head Start,labeling our children,Learning disability?,No MORE Recess???,Uncategorized and have No Comments

Make it a GREAT START to school by EDUCATION WEEK

View the most popular stories your colleagues are reading on Education Week
1. What to Do the First Day of School (and Why)
2. Why Ed Tech Is Not Transforming How Teachers Teach
3. 10 Critical Issues Facing Education
4. Districts Facing Teacher Shortages Look for Lifelines
5. Common-Core Algebra Seen as Tougher
6. Why a ‘Growth Mindset’ Won’t Work
7. New Read-Aloud Strategies Transform Story Time
8. Co-Teaching for Rookies: Classroom Organization and Managing Details
9. 3 Things You Can Do This Summer to Be a Better Teacher in the Fall
10. Hurdles in Pairing General, Special Education Teachers
11. Teachers: Know When to Stop Talking (Commentary)
12. Parent Engagement on Rise as Priority for Schools, Districts
Enjoy some of these trending articles and blog posts, and please consider subscribing so you can always stay on top of the changes in policy and practice impacting your profession. Save 20% or more when you subscribe to PRINT + DIGITAL or save 22% when you subscribe to ALL DIGITAL.


shemmingson signature
Stefanie Hemmingson
Director, Audience Development
Follow us:
Education Week on Twitter Education Week Facebook Page Education Week on LinkedIn Education Week on Google+ All RSS feeds


posted by lgilliam in "SOS" SAVE OUR STUDENTS!,Brain Study in Girls and Boys,Coaching,Concern for boys learning,Educational Frustrations,Head Start,Heroes of schools,labeling our children,Learning disability?,No MORE Recess???,Uncategorized and have No Comments